Masamu a Roulette · Mfundo · mphindi 10

Chinyengo cha Wotchova Juga

Chikhulupiriro chakuti zotsatira “zafika nthawi yake” chifukwa sizinatuluke kwa kanthawi.

Yankho lalifupi

Pambuyo pa zofiira khumi kuthekera kwa zakuda kudakali 18/37. Gudumu silisunga mbiri ndipo silikongola kanthu.

p(zakuda pambuyo pa zofiira 10)
48.65%
p(zakuda pambuyo pa zofiira 0)
48.65%
Monte Carlo, 1913
zakuda 26
imatchedwanso
chinyengo cha Monte Carlo

Chinyengocho

If redbetchaZofiiraBetcha la even-money pa manambala 18 ofiira. Mu Chifalansa: rouge.Werengani yonse → has come up ten times, many players feel that blackbetchaZakudaBetcha la even-money pa manambala 18 akuda. Mu Chifalansa: noir.Werengani yonse → is “due” and bet accordingly. Others feel red is “hot” and bet that. Both are reasoning from a sequence that is already over to a spin that has not happened. In the fair single-zerogudumuZiroKabowo kamodzi kobiriwira kamene betcha la even-money, dazeni kapena mzati siliphimba; gwero la phindu la kasino. Imatchedwanso: ziro imodzi, 0.Werengani yonse → model with independent spinsmasamuKuzungulira kodziyimira payokhaKuzungulira kulikonse kuli ndi kuthekera kofanana mosasamala kanthu za mbiri. Maziko a kuwerengera kulikonse pa tsamba lino.Werengani yonse →, the next-spin probabilitymasamuKuthekeraMwayi wa zotsatira, kuchokera 0 mpaka 1 kapena 0% mpaka 100%. Nambala imodzi: 1/37 = 2.70%.Werengani yonse → of black remains 18/37.

Nthano: Manambala Ndi Oyenera Kutuluka

N’chifukwa chiyani kumamveka ngati koona

Under the independent fair-wheel model, the proportions of red and black each tend toward 18/37 as the sample grows. This does not require a compensating run of black. After ten initial reds and N further spins, expected red and black counts differ by ten, while the contribution of those initial reds to the total proportion becomes smaller. Actual counts still fluctuate.

pambuyo pa zofiira 10, kenako kuzungulira kwachilungamo Nzofiira zoyembekezekazakuda zoyembekezekagawo la zofiira
N = 0100100%
N = 10058.6548.6553.32%
N = 1,000496.49486.4949.16%
N = 100,00048,658.6548,648.6548.65%
Kuchuluka kwa zofiira khumi sikutha konse. Kumangosiya kukhala kofunika.

Monte Carlo, 18 August 1913

Zakuda zinatuluka ka 26 motsatizana pa tebulo lina mu Casino de Monte-Carlo. Kuyambira pa zakuda pafupifupi za khumi ndi zisanu, osewera anaunjikana pa zofiira, akuwirikiza ndi kuwirikizanso, kuzungulira kulikonse “kotsimikizika kwambiri” kuposa koyamba. Kasino inapambana mamiliyoni a ma franc. Zotsatizanazo zinali ndi kuthekera kwa 1 pa 137 miliyoni kuchokera pa zakuda zoyamba, ndipo kuthekera koti zichitike pamapeto pake kwinakwake m’makasino a padziko lonse kunali kwenikweni kumodzi. Ichi ndicho chifukwa chake chinyengo cha wotchova juga chimatchedwanso chinyengo cha Monte Carlo.

Zotsatizana za 1913, monga chinyengo chinaziwonera
zakuda × 5

Palibe chachilendo. Zimachitika kamodzi pa 44.

zakuda × 10

Osewera ayamba kuzindikira. Zofiira “zafika nthawi yake”.

zakuda × 15

Tebulo ladzaza. Ndalama zobetcha pa zofiira zimawirikizidwa pambuyo pa kuluza kulikonse.

zakuda × 20

Chuma chatayika. Zakuda zatsopano zilizonse zimapangitsa zofiira kuoneka zotsimikizika kwambiri.

zakuda × 26

Zotsatizana zatha. Kasino yapambana mamiliyoni a ma franc kuchokera kwa anthu obetcha motsutsana ndi zotsatizana zimene sizikanatha “kudziwa” kuti zinali zotsatizana.

Casino de Monte-Carlo

Dzanja lotentha (hot hand)

Kuthandizira mtundu chifukwa ukutsatizana ndi kulakwa komweko kotembenuzidwa: zotsatizana zikuyembekezeka kupitirira m’malo motha. Akatswiri a maganizo amazitcha dzanja lotenthanthanoDzanja lotenthaChikhulupiriro chakuti kupambana motsatizana, kapena zotsatira zimodzimodzi motsatizana, kumapangitsa china kukhala chotheka kwambiri. Pa gudumu ndi chinyengo cha wotchova juga chotembenuzidwa.Werengani yonse →, potsatira kafukufuku wa 1985 wa Gilovich, Vallone ndi Tversky amene anafufuza zotsatizana pa kuponya mpira wa basketball ndipo sanapeze zina kupatula za mwangozi. Mu 2018 Miller ndi Sanjurjo anaonetsa kuti mayesowo anali opendekeka: m’mbiri yaifupi, gawo la kugunda pambuyo pa kugunda limatuluka pansi pa mlingo wonse wa woponya pa avareji, choncho wosewera wopanda dzanja lotentha konse amaoneka wozizira pang’ono. Atakonzedwa, zambiri zomwezo zimaonetsa dzanja lotentha pang’ono. Munthu angathe kutentha; gudumu lilibe mkhalidwe woti likhalemo. Osewera ena amakhulupirira zonse ziwiri nthawi imodzi, kuti zotsatizana zimapitirira mpaka “zitalika kwambiri” kenako zimatha. Pa gudumu lachilungamo mtundu uliwonse wa chikhulupiriro uli ndi mtengo woyembekezekamasamuMtengo woyembekezekaZotsatira zapakati pa betcha lililonse pa nthawi yayitali. −1/37 ya ndalama zobetcha pa betcha lililonse la ku Ulaya wamba.Werengani yonse → wofanana ndi kusankha mtundu poponya ndalama: −2.70% ya ndalama zobetcha.

Kuthekera kwa Zotsatizana mu Roulette

Pa tebulo lenileni

Croson and Sundali (2005) watched 18 hours of security video from one double-zero table at a large casino in Reno: 139 players placing 24,131 bets. On the even-money betsbetchaBetcha la even-moneyZofiira/zakuda, osakhala awiriawiri/awiriawiri, okwera/otsika. Manambala 18, amalipira 1:1.Werengani yonse →, players were about evenly divided between following short runs and opposing them. After five of a kind in a row they leaned against the run, and after six or more, 85% of their bets were on the other side. The same players showed the hot hand about themselves: after a win on the numbers they covered 13.6 numbers on the next spin on average, against 9.2 after a loss. The study found no statistically significant evidence of wheel bias. These are observations from one table, and the authors discuss alternative explanations for changes in betting after wins.

Kunja kwa kasino

Kukoka komweko kumaonekera kumene zisankho zenizeni zimapangidwa. Clotfelter ndi Cook (1993) anatsatira masewera a manambala a tsiku ndi tsiku a Maryland: ndalama zobetchedwa pa nambala zinatsika kwambiri itangotulutsidwa ndipo zinatenga miyezi kuti zibwerere, ngakhale kuti kutulutsa kulibe kukumbukira. Chen, Moskowitz ndi Shue (2016) anachipeza pakati pa akatswiri. Oweruza a milandu yopempha chitetezo (asylum) ku United States anali ndi mwayi wokwera mpaka 3.3 percentage points wokana mlandu ngati anavomereza wapitawo. Oyimbira a baseball anali ndi mwayi wotsika ndi 1.5 points woyimba strike atangoyimba ina, ndipo kuposa kuwirikiza kawiri pa maponyedwe a mkangano. M’kuyesa kwa m’munda ndi akuluakulu a ngongole olipidwa malipiro osasintha, mpaka 9% ya zisankho zinatembenuzidwa motere. Milanduyo inabwera mwachisawawa, choncho chisankho chomaliza sichinanene kanthu za chotsatira, monga momwe kuzungulira komaliza sikunena kanthu za kotsatira.

Oyimbira oweruza maponyedwe a mkangano anali ndi mwayi wotsika woyimba strike atangoyimba ina.

Chinyengo cha wotchova juga chotembenuzidwa

Katswiri wa nzeru Ian Hacking (1987) anatchula mtundu wachitatu. Munthu walowa m’chipinda, waona madayisi awiri akugwera pa sikisi ziwiri ndipo wamaliza kuti ayenera kuti aponyedwa kale kambirimbiri. Kuponya kulikonse kuli ndi mwayi wofanana wotuluka sikisi ziwiri, koyamba madzulo kapena ka chikwi, choncho chooneka chimenecho sichinena kanthu za kutalika kwa nthawi imene masewera akhala akuchitika. Mu roulette ndi wosewera amene afika pa bolodi loonetsa zofiira zisanu ndi zitatu ndipo asankha kuti tebulo liyenera kuti lakhala likuzungulira kwa maola kuti zichitike. Chinyengo chamba chimawerenga zakale mu kuzungulira kotsatira; ichi chimawerenga chooneka chosowa m’zakale zimene palibe anaziona.

Katswiri wa maganizo amene anachikhulupirira

Chinyengochi chakhala ndi oteteza ophunzira. Katswiri wa maganizo wa ku Germany Karl Marbe anafufuza m’mabuku anayi olembera obadwa, iliyonse ya obadwa 49,152, anapeza kuti zotsatizana zazitali kwambiri za anyamata kapena za atsikana motsatizana zinali 17, ndipo anamaliza kuti zotsatizana zazitali ndi zosowa kuposa mmene mwangozi kumalolera, kotero kuti zotsatizana zimapangitsa zotsatira zina kukhala zotheka kwambiri. Mwangozi kokha kumanena mosiyana: pa obadwa 196,608 zotsatizana za 17 kapena kuposa zimaonekera pafupifupi kanayi pa kasanu. Marbe anapeza ndendende mmene zotsatizana zachisawawa zimaonekera. Epstein (2013) amafotokozanso nkhaniyi; Kuthekera kwa Zotsatizana mu Roulette imapereka mtundu wa roulette.

Karl Marbe akufufuza m’mabuku olembera obadwa kuti apeze zotsatizana zazitali za anyamata kapena za atsikana.

Kumene chinyengo sichigwira ntchito

If the wheel were physically biased, past spins would be informative, because they would be evidence about the pocketszipangizoKabowoChimodzi mwa tibowo 37 tokhala ndi manambala pa rotor. Kamatchedwanso: slot, cup.Werengani yonse → rather than about luck. That is the Lab’s subject. The sample required depends on the size of the bias, the test and the acceptable error rates. A short streak alone does not distinguish bias from chance; comparing explanations also requires assumptions about how plausible each was before the data.

Kukula kwa Chitsanzo

Mafunso

Kodi chinyengochi chimakhudza roulette yokha?

Ayi. Chimakhudza chochitika chilichonse chobwerezedwa chodziyimira payokha: madayisi, ndalama zoponya, manambala a lotale.

Ngati ndibetcha zakuda pa kuzungulira 1,000, kodi zofiira ndi zakuda sizidzafanana?

With more independent spins, the proportions tend toward their probabilities; they do not have to be close after any fixed number. Standard single-zero bets have an expected lossmasamuKutayika koyembekezekaMtengo woyembekezeka kuchulukitsa ndi ndalama zonse zobetchedwa; kuchuluka kwapakati kwa ndalama zotayika mu gawo la masewera kapena nthawi inayake.Werengani yonse → of 2.70% of turnoverndalamaNdalama zonse zobetchedwaNdalama zonse zobetchedwa mu gawo la masewera kapena nthawi inayake, kuphatikizapo ndalama zopambana zobetchedwanso. Zimatchedwanso: handle, action.Werengani yonse →, but your actual result can be far from that average.

Nanga bwanji lamulo la avareji?

Palibe lamulo la avareji. Pali lamulo la manambala akuluakulumasamuLamulo la manambala akuluakuluAvareji ya zotsatira zodziyimira payokha imayandikira mtengo woyembekezeka pamene chiwerengero cha mayesero chikukula.Werengani yonse →, ndipo limagwira ntchito mwa kusungunula.

Masamu Osangalatsa

Yesani nokha choyamba. Yankho lililonse labisika; litsegulireni mukakonzeka.

  1. Pambuyo pa kuponya ndalama ka 10 ikusonyeza mitu 7 ndi michira 3. Pambuyo pa kuponya ka 1,000 ikusonyeza mitu 517 ndi michira 483. Kodi michira inapeza mitu?

    Onetsani yankho

    Yankho Ayi. Kusiyana kunakula kuchokera pa 4 kufika pa 34. Chiyerekezo chokha ndicho chinayandikira kufanana.

    The ratio of heads to tails fell from 7/3, about 2.33, to 517/483, about 1.07. This example illustrates how a proportion can move closer to one-half while the count difference grows.

    The gap between them grew, from 4 to 34. With a fair coin a gap of around 30 after 1,000 tosses is ordinary: the typical gap grows roughly with the square root of the number of tosses, while the ratio settles toward 1.

    Nothing pulled the tails back. The early surplus of heads was diluted by the next 990 tosses, not corrected.

  2. Ponyani ndalama kanayi ndipo yang’anani kuponya kokha kumene kumabwera pambuyo pa mutu. Kodi ndi gawo lanji la kumeneko limene ndi mitu? Werengerani pa ndandanda iliyonse mwa 16 zotheka ndipo tengani avareji ya magawowo. Kodi ndi 50%?

    Onetsani yankho

    Yankho Ayi. Ndi 17/42, pafupifupi 40.5%. Poyang’ana motere, ndalama yachilungamo imaoneka ngati ikuzizira pambuyo pa mutu.

    Lembani ndandanda 16 (H = mutu, T = mchira). Ziwiri mwa izo, TTTT ndi TTTH, zilibe mutu m’kuponya katatu koyamba, choncho palibe chimene chimatsatira mutu; zimenezo zimasiya 14.

    Pa iliyonse, tengani kuponya kotsatira mutu ndipo pezani gawo limene ndi mitu. HHHH imapereka 3 mwa 3. HHHT imapereka 2 mwa 3. HTHT imapereka 0 mwa 2. Kudutsa zonse 14: ndandanda zisanu ndi imodzi zimapereka 0, zinayi zimapereka 1/2, imodzi imapereka 2/3 ndipo zitatu zimapereka 1 (HHHH, THHH ndi TTHH).

    Phatikizani magawo: 4 × 1/2 + 2/3 + 3 = 17/3. Gawani ndi 14: 17/42 ≈ 40.5%.

    Palibe kuponya kumene kumakonda michira; kulikonse ndi 50–50. Kupendekeka kumachokera pa kutenga avareji ndandanda ndi ndandanda: ndandanda yodzaza ndi mitu ili ndi kuponya kochuluka koyang’ana koma imawerengedwa kamodzi, mofanana ndi ndandanda yokhala ndi umodzi wokha. Miller ndi Sanjurjo (2018) anasonyeza kuti kafukufuku wa “dzanja lotentha” wa 1985 anayeza osewera ake a basketball motere, choncho osewera amene ankaoneka kuti alibe zotsatizana kuposa mwangozi kwenikweni anali ndi zotsatizana pang’ono.

Nthabwala yopumitsa

Kusungunula, osati kukonza. Gudumu silikongola kanthu.

Kusungunula, osati kukonza. Gudumu silikongola kanthu.

Magwero

  1. Feller, W. An Introduction to Probability Theory and Its Applications, Vol. 1. Wiley, kope la 3, 1968. Gambler’s ruin, mutu XIV.
  2. Schwartz, D. G. Roll the Bones: The History of Gambling. Gotham, 2006.
  3. Ethier, S. N. The Doctrine of Chances: Probabilistic Aspects of Gambling. Springer, 2010. Mutu 13, roulette.
  4. Epstein, R. A. The Theory of Gambling and Statistical Logic, 2nd ed. Academic Press, 2013.
  5. Croson, R. & Sundali, J. “The gambler’s fallacy and the hot hand: empirical data from casinos.” Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 30(3), 2005.
  6. Chen, D. L., Moskowitz, T. J. & Shue, K. “Decision making under the gambler’s fallacy: evidence from asylum judges, loan officers, and baseball umpires.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 131(3), 2016; ziwerengero kuchokera ku NBER Working Paper 22026.
  7. Clotfelter, C. T. & Cook, P. J. “The ‘gambler’s fallacy’ in lottery play.” Management Science 39(12), 1993.
  8. Gilovich, T., Vallone, R. & Tversky, A. “The hot hand in basketball: on the misperception of random sequences.” Cognitive Psychology 17(3), 1985.
  9. Miller, J. B. & Sanjurjo, A. “Surprised by the hot hand fallacy? A truth in the law of small numbers.” Econometrica 86(6), 2018.
  10. Hacking, I. “The inverse gambler’s fallacy: the argument from design. The anthropic principle applied to Wheeler universes.” Mind 96(383), 1987.
chitsanzo: ya ku Ulaya, ziro imodzinjira zowerengera ↗magwero ↗