Labu ya Roulette · Labu · Ziwerengero · mphindi 8

Kufunika kwa Ziwerengero

“Kofunika” (significant) kumatanthauza kosatheka kwambiri pansi pa gudumu lachilungamo, osati “kwenikweni” ndipo osati “kopindulitsa”.

Yankho lalifupi

p-value ya 0.05 imatanthauza kuti gudumu lachilungamo likanapanga kalembedwe kopendekeka chotere kamodzi pa makumi awiri. Mukayang’ana magudumu makumi awiri, limodzi lidzapambana mayeso mwangozi.

mwambo
p < 0.05
mlingo wa zotsatira zabodza
5% pa mayeso aliwonse
kukonza
kubwereza
zimene si
p(gudumu ndi lokondera)

Kodi p-value ndi chiyani

Assuming the stated null model, the p-valuelabup-valueKuthekera koona kupatuka kofanana kapena kokulirapo kuposa komwe kwaonedwa ngati gudumu likanakhala lachilungamo.Werengani yonse → is the probabilitymasamuKuthekeraMwayi wa zotsatira, kuchokera 0 mpaka 1 kapena 0% mpaka 100%. Nambala imodzi: 1/37 = 2.70%.Werengani yonse → of a test statistic at least as extreme as the observed one. It is not the probability that the wheel is fair or that the result arose by chance. Interpretation also depends on the design, assumptions and tests attempted.

chonenacholondola?
p = 0.03 imatanthauza kuti gudumu lachilungamo limapereka zambiri zopitirira chotere 3% ya nthawiinde
p = 0.03 imatanthauza kuti pali mwayi wa 97% woti gudumu ndi lokonderaayi
p = 0.03 imatanthauza kuti kabowo kotentha kadzakhalabe kotenthaayi
p = 0.03 mutayang’ana magudumu 30 ndi umboni wamphamvuayi; mumayembekezera zotsatira zotere imodzi kapena ziwiri mwangozi
p = 0.03 kawiri, pa zitsanzo ziwiri zodziyimira payokha kuchokera pa gudumu lomwelotsopano n’koyenera kusamala

Kuyerekeza kangapo

Mayeso aliwonse amene mumachita pa gudumu lachilungamo ali ndi mwayi wa 5% wopambana pa mlingo wa 5%. Yesani magudumu makumi awiri ndipo limodzi limapambana. Yesani gudumu limodzi pa nthawi makumi awiri zosiyana ndipo imodzi imapambana. Yesani chitsanzo chimodzi ndi magulu 37 a kabowozipangizoKabowoChimodzi mwa tibowo 37 tokhala ndi manambala pa rotor. Kamatchedwanso: slot, cup.Werengani yonse →, magulu asanu ndi limodzi a gawogudumuGawoMndandanda wolumikizana wa tibowo pa gudumu, mosiyana ndi gulu pa dongosolo la mabetcha.Werengani yonse → ndi magulu atatu a mtundu ndipo china chake chimapambana. Mankhwala ake ndi kusankha mayeso musanayang’ane zambiri, kuwachita kamodzi, ndi kutsimikiza pa zambiri zatsopano. Kuyang’anayang’ana kumene kumapeza gudumu “lokondera” kawirikawiri ndiko kumene kunapanga zotsatirazo.

Mwayi wa zotsatira zabodza imodzi pang’ono pa p < 0.05%
mayeso 1
5%
mayeso 5
22.6%
mayeso 10
40.1%
mayeso 20
64.2%
mayeso 37 (amodzi pa kabowo kalikonse)
85.0%
%
042.5085.0%
1 − 0.95ⁿ. Kuyesa kabowo kalikonse kokha kuli pafupifupi kotsimikizika kupeza kamodzi “kofunika”.

Kufunika poyerekeza ndi kukula

A large sample can detect a small departure from fairness that still does not make a bet profitable. At a true pocket probability of 1/36.5, a 35:1 bet has negative expectation. At 1/36 it breaks even. A p-value does not measure the size or practical value of an effect.

Mphamvu (power)

Power is the chance of rejecting the null under a specified alternative. For one pocket chosen in advance, an exact one-sided 5% binomial test on 1,000 spins rejects at 37 or more hits. If the true rate is 1/30, its power is about 28%, not 50%.

Muyezo wothandiza

Kuti chonena cha kukondera chikhale chosangalatsa: mayeso osankhidwa pasadakhale, p < 0.01 m’malo mwa 0.05, kubwereza pa chitsanzo chodziyimira payokha cha kukula kofanana, ndi mlingo woyerekezeka wa kugunda pa tibowo tokondedwa wa 1/34 kapena kuposa pambuyo pobwereza. Muyezo umenewo wakwaniritsidwa kangapo kochepa m’mbiri ya masewerawa ndipo sunakwaniritsidwe konse, monga mmene zolembedwa zapoyera zikuonetsera, pa gudumu lamakono losamalidwa.

Mafunso

N’chifukwa chiyani 0.05?

Mwambo wochokera m’ma 1920. Palibe chapadera pa iwo; 0.01 ndi malire omveka bwino pamene mukuyang’ana magudumu ambiri.

Ngati p ndi yaing’ono kwambiri, kodi gudumu ndi lokondera ndithu?

Mwina silikupanga zotsatira zofanana. Zingakhale zotsatira za dealer, cholakwika cholemba kapena vuto lolowetsa zambiri. Bwerezani.

Kodi zotsatira zofunika zimandiuza kabowo koti ndibetche?

No. That requires a separate estimate of hit probability, its uncertainty and the actual payoutndalamaMalipiroZimene betcha lopambana limabweza, zotchulidwa ngati “X ku 1” kuwonjezera pa ndalama zobetcha zobwezedwa.Werengani yonse →.

Masamu Osangalatsa

Yesani nokha choyamba. Yankho lililonse labisika; litsegulireni mukakonzeka.

  1. Suppose a dozenbetchaDazeni1–12, 13–24 kapena 25–36, amalipira 2:1.Werengani yonse → chosen before data collection appears 742 times in 3,000 independent double-zerogudumuZiroKabowo kamodzi kobiriwira kamene betcha la even-money, dazeni kapena mzati siliphimba; gwero la phindu la kasino. Imatchedwanso: ziro imodzi, 0.Werengani yonse → spins. Under the uniform model, how many standard deviationsmasamuKupatuka kokhazikikaMuzu wa sikweya wa kusinthasintha; mtunda wanthawi zonse wa zotsatira kuchokera ku mtengo woyembekezeka.Werengani yonse → below the mean is that? What is the probabilitymasamuKuthekeraMwayi wa zotsatira, kuchokera 0 mpaka 1 kapena 0% mpaka 100%. Nambala imodzi: 1/37 = 2.70%.Werengani yonse → of 742 or fewer hits?

    Onetsani yankho

    Yankho Pafupifupi makupatuka okhazikika 8.1 pansi. Gudumu lachilungamo likanachita zimenezo pafupifupi kamodzi pa kuyesa 3 × 10¹⁵, kutanthauza kuti sizingachitike konse. Yankho lofalitsidwa pamodzi ndi funsoli likuti 11.75; ife tikupeza 8.07.

    Under the stated model, X is binomial with n = 3,000 and p = 12/38. Its mean is np ≈ 947.37 and its standard deviation is √(np(1 − p)) ≈ 25.46.

    The standardized difference is (742 − 947.37)/25.46 ≈ −8.07. Summing the exact binomial probabilities from 0 through 742 gives P(X ≤ 742) ≈ 9.77 × 10⁻¹⁷. A normal approximation with continuity correction gives about 4.25 × 10⁻¹⁶; the relative error is large this far into the tail.

    This is the probability of the specified data event under the model, not the probability that the wheel is fair. Such a result calls for checking the observations, independence, uniformity and analysis plan. Selecting the worst-looking dozen after inspecting data, or searching many wheels or time periods, requires accounting for that selection.

Nthabwala yopumitsa

Gudumu limodzi pa magudumu achilungamo makumi awiri ndi “lofunika”. Ndilo tanthauzo la nambalayo.

Gudumu limodzi pa magudumu achilungamo makumi awiri ndi “lofunika”. Ndilo tanthauzo la nambalayo.

Magwero

  1. Pearson, K. “On the criterion that a given system of deviations from the probable…” https://www.amstat.org/asa/files/pdfs/P-ValueStatement.pdf
  2. Feller, W. An Introduction to Probability Theory and Its Applications, Vol. 1. https://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/software/dataplot/refman1/auxillar/chsqgood.htm
chitsanzo: ya ku Ulaya, ziro imodzinjira zowerengera ↗magwero ↗